Meal delivery boxes are a brutal business.
I’ve looked at HelloFresh, Blue Apron, a couple of others. And the numbers are kind of mind-boggling.
Here’s the napkin math of why this business would be my personal hell.
First, the TAM (total addressable market).
I actually wrote a previous newsletter on just this problem:
The market looks enormous until you count the people who will actually buy.
Because you start saying things like, “Well, everybody eats dinner. So even if we just got 1% of that…” without realizing that’s an insane target.
Your actual TAM is much smaller: people with money, time, and interest in cooking.
Then, the product.
One box costs about $57.
About $38 of that goes to food, packaging, and shipping.
That leaves $19 to cover software, offices, and marketing.
One big problem: your fixed costs barely scale at all. Software costs almost $0 to sell the thousandth time. Raw chicken, ice packs, and a FedEx truck cost the same every week.
Then, the profit margin.
The numbers aren’t all public here, but there are a few to go by.
Blue Apron's IPO filing said it cost $94 to land a customer. But that was averaged all the way back to 2014. By 2017, one estimate put it at about $460.
So does $460 earn out?
In 2016, a customer spent $387 in their first six months.
Subtract the fixed costs, you’re left with about $130 gross profit.
So you’re still $330 in the red on your customer acquisition cost. But you’ve got a subscriber!
… except they’re some of the least sticky customers. Only about 1 in 4 customers were still around after six months.
The results
Blue Apron never had a profitable year. At the peak, they were valued at $2 billion. In 2023, the whole company sold for $103 million.
Albertsons bought Plated for a reported $200 million in 2017. It shut down the subscription two years later.
Arguably the “winner” of this bloodbath was HelloFresh. But their revenue fell 11% last year. U.S. sales fell almost 17%. The stock is down 93% from its 2021 peak.
HelloFresh now says it's going after "a smaller yet more profitable number of customers."
TOGETHER WITH COMPOUND CONFERENCE
I'd rather pick a small niche and serve it well. Compound is me taking my own advice: 150 operators max at Sundance, Feb 8–11, 2027.
The people there are holdco builders, acquisition entrepreneurs and owners growing through bolt-ons. You'll spend part of the three days in a small group with operators in your sector, working through a problem one of you is actually dealing with.
Black Friday pricing is still on: BFCM takes $1,250 off through Friday, Dec 4. After that, it's back to full price. Get your ticket.
How I think about it
TAM: Selling to “every home in America” is a pipe dream. You’ll never have anything specific to say. I’d always rather choose a small niche and serve them well.
Product: I love software because it’s the ultimate scalable product. Build once, sell it forever with practically zero fixed costs.(And I’ve done this from both sides — the family business is fireworks. I am very familiar with having to worry about warehouses full of literal explosives.)
Profit: Plenty of big companies run at a loss for years. Sometimes it works out (like Uber). But plenty of times it doesn’t, and if you don’t have venture capital pouring investment dollars into the business, you’re in big trouble.
If your customer lifetime value was –$330… I’d suggest you find a new game to play.
Good luck out there.
Michael
P.S. Own a business in Dallas or New York? Come hang out with other business owners.
My friends at Scalepath are hosting two private happy hours for local business owners next month:
- Dallas (Flower Mound area): Tuesday, Dec 8, 6-9 PM
- New York (Midtown Manhattan): Thursday, Dec 10, 6:30-9 PM
These are owners-only, invite-only evenings. No pitching, no vendors, just a relaxed room of people who run real businesses (the bar is $1M+ in annual revenue) and get what you deal with every day.
Space is limited. If you own a business in either area and want an invite, email Rand at [email protected] with a line or two about your company.
—
FREE EVENTS COMING UP
Thu Dec 3 • 12 CT / 1 ET
Year End Tax Moves for Business Owners
with Michael Girdley and Mitchell Baldridge
Wed Dec 9 • 9 CT / 10 ET
Buying a Business in 2027 (and What AI Changes About It)
with Bill D’Alessandro and Tim Ericson (Acquisition Lab)
Thu Jan 14 • 12 CT / 1 ET
Managing Humans in the AI Age
with Dave Kline and Michael Girdley
Other ways I can help…
The Low-Risk Business → 30 years of building, turned into one playbook
Hire With Near → Build high-performing remote teams for 70% less
Bedrock → Validate the numbers before you buy a business
Compound Conference → where business owners figure out their next move